BeanoWild vs KaiMakesMusic: Difference between revisions
| Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
=== The Tape Debate === | === The Tape Debate === | ||
To further investigate, [[Znop]] | To further investigate, [[Znop]] ran the audio through an analog tape system and returned it to BeanoWild. When Beano applied the same invert phasing techniques to this version, the song exhibited expected phase behavior—consistent with other Michael Jackson songs produced by Bryan Loren, the producer of Man In Black. | ||
This result reignited debate. While BeanoWild saw this as evidence that the original track had not passed through analog equipment (and was thus likely fake), both KaiMakesMusic and fellow supporter [[Zecon]] countered that the observed phasing behavior was a natural result of analog tape processing. They argued that many tracks from the era could have been preserved or produced using digital formats such as DAT (Digital Audio Tape), which would explain the lack of analog characteristics. | This result reignited debate. While BeanoWild saw this as evidence that the original track had not passed through analog equipment (and was thus likely fake), both KaiMakesMusic and fellow supporter [[Zecon]] countered that the observed phasing behavior was a natural result of analog tape processing. They argued that many tracks from the era could have been preserved or produced using digital formats such as DAT (Digital Audio Tape), which would explain the lack of analog characteristics. | ||
Revision as of 07:52, 11 April 2025
BeanoWild vs KaiMakesMusic refers to a community dispute surrounding the authenticity of the leaked Michael Jackson track titled Man In Black. The debate began within the MJSD community following the leak of the song, which sparked controversy regarding its origins and legitimacy.
Background
In early discussions following the leak of Man In Black, speculation emerged over whether the track was an authentic Michael Jackson recording or an AI-generated fake. The two primary figures in the debate were community members KaiMakesMusic and BeanoWild.
KaiMakesMusic firmly asserted that the song was genuine, citing its production quality and stylistic consistency with early 1990s Michael Jackson recordings. In an effort to strengthen his claim, Kai later released the full version of Man In Black to the public.
BeanoWild, known within the community for his advanced audio engineering skills, countered Kai’s claim by arguing that the track was AI-generated. Using invert phasing techniques—a method of detecting phase cancellation in audio—Beano attempted to analyze the song's production chain. According to Beano, the file lacked the kind of phase inversion artifacts typically seen in analog recordings, suggesting that the track had only existed in a digital environment. Given the early 1990s timeframe of the supposed recording, this lack of analog tape involvement was seen as suspicious.
The Tape Debate
To further investigate, Znop ran the audio through an analog tape system and returned it to BeanoWild. When Beano applied the same invert phasing techniques to this version, the song exhibited expected phase behavior—consistent with other Michael Jackson songs produced by Bryan Loren, the producer of Man In Black.
This result reignited debate. While BeanoWild saw this as evidence that the original track had not passed through analog equipment (and was thus likely fake), both KaiMakesMusic and fellow supporter Zecon countered that the observed phasing behavior was a natural result of analog tape processing. They argued that many tracks from the era could have been preserved or produced using digital formats such as DAT (Digital Audio Tape), which would explain the lack of analog characteristics.
Ongoing Dispute
The conversation continued in a back-and-forth fashion, with both sides presenting technical evidence and interpretations to support their claims. While BeanoWild remained skeptical due to the absence of analog tape indicators in the original file, KaiMakesMusic maintained that the song's authenticity was legitimate and in line with known practices of the era.
As of now, the debate remains unresolved, with no definitive proof confirming or debunking the song’s authenticity. The discussion continues to be a notable topic of interest within the MJSD community with multiple members like thehelper39, Goku San and sapped46 expressing frustration and boredom with the subject.
